Is it really wrong to have daal and curd together?

Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator

Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator

Her fitness mantra is “do not start with a diet that has an expiration date, instead, focus on a healthy lifestyle that will last forever”. Disti has completed post graduation in Clinical Nutrition and Dietetics. She isalso a certified Diabetes Educator.
She iskeen on bringing together her acquired knowledge on nutrition and other health aspects with people’s goals to achieve a healthy life. For her fitness is not being better than someone else; it’s about being better than who we used to be. “We don’t have to be great to start, but we have to start to be great". So give your best!
Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator

Latest posts by Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator (see all)

Did you know that wrong food combinations can cause severe gastric issues?

Since childhood my mom taught me what combinations I should not take together.  She never allowed us to have milk and fruits together, daal and curd together, and for a lot of people it is no fish and milk products together.

I always wondered why. Did you as well?

For my family it was always religious ritual and for others it might just be a rule, but I always wanted to find the reason behind it. This curiosity made me search and write on the science behind food combination.

So yes this belief does have scientific reasoning and to my surprise AYURVEDA supports this.

So before moving to the combinations let us understand what happens to food after we ingest it.

[Editor’s Note: Article Contains Ayurvedic Claims that are not entirely in line with modern medicine. Reader’s discretion advised! References are provided at the end]

 

According to AYURVEDA,  every food has its own taste known as “rasa”, a heating or cooling energy called “virya” and a post digestive effect “vipaka” , some will also posses “prabhava” an unexplained effect.

Our gastric fire or “AGNI” largely determines how well or poorly food is digested.

The AGNI can get overloaded if 2 or more different ingredient having different taste and energy are combined. This overload can inhibit the enzyme system and lead to production of innumerable toxins in the body.

Different food groups have different digestion time, and when we combine foods which have roughly the same digestion time, the process becomes easier.

If the food that goes inside the stomach is not digested properly it can cause indigestion, fermentation, putrefaction (process where the consumed food rotten) and gas formation and if prolonged it can lead to toxemia and diseases.

 

On the other side correct food combinations will aid digestion, utilization and right absorption of nutrients.

Each food will require a different environment to aid the digestion process some will require an acid environment and for some it will be alkaline. So I’m sure the chemistry students know this – Acids and Alkali neutralize each other, which in turn hampers the digestion process. Proteins will require an acidic environment to digest whereas the starches, sugars or fruits will require an alkaline environment, so when such combinations are combined the digestion can be hampered.

Too much of theory isn’t it?

So let’s jump to some combinations through which you can link the above theory and understand things in a better way.

 

 1. Milk with Fruits

Milk is best when taken alone as it’s a concentrated food by itself.

  Milk does not allow the food to mix with saliva, which makes digestion difficult.

Milk constitutes of both fats and proteins which after reaching the intestine coagulates to form curd.

Further this curd does not allow gastric juices (which help in digestion process) to act upon the food, because it surrounds the starches that are eaten along with milk.

The starches are digested only after the milk curd is digested.

Also milk is digested in the duodenum whereas most of the other food is digested in the stomach; therefore foods combined with it remain undigested.

When taken together they can change intestinal flora , produce toxins , allergies , cough , cold , congestions etc

Effect of Viruddha Anna on Digestive System

 

For eg – Milk with citrus fruits, bananas, melons.

Eating milk and banana together can change the intestinal flora, produce toxins, allergies, cough, cold, congestions etc

 

2. Two different proteins should not be consumed together

This means that different kind of proteins from the same category can be taken together, but not the totally different ones.

For e.g. – Almonds and walnuts can be taken together, but not fish and curd.

Proteins from different groups have different time and type for release of digestive secretions.

For instance – if we consider milk, strongest juices are released when milk is consumed in the last hours of digestion. Same way eggs receive strongest secretions at different time compared to that with flesh or milk.

Therefore it becomes very difficult for the body to meet the requirement of 2 proteins at the same meal.

 

3. Acidic or Sour foods should not be combined with proteins

In the presence of sour or acidic foods in the stomach, gastric juices may not be released.

They also interfere in the digestion of proteins by either destroying pepsin ( a digestive enzyme that chemically breaks down protein into shorter chains of amino acids )  inhibits hydrochloric acid secretion ( helps in digestion)

This combination when taken together may badly affect protein digestion and cause putrefaction (process of rotting).

Example of acidic fruits are oranges, plums, tomatoes, pineapple, pomegranate, tamarind, grapes etc

Curd is also acidic in nature therefore should be avoided with daals.

 

4. Acidic fruits should not be combined with sweet fruits

Acidic fruits slow down the quick digestion of sugars present in sweet fruits which leads to fermentation.

Examples of sour foods are listed above

Sweet fruits – bananas, sapota (chickoo) , papaya , dates , sweet berries etc

 

 5. Avoid eating too many fats alongside proteins

Fat may depress the release of gastric juices required in the digestion process. This may reduce the speed of digestion by 50%

Heated or fried foods or fat insulated foods remain in the stomach for a long time and cause a lot of strain.

Therefore putting too much fat on daal or frying daal will be digested slowly.

Same rationales apply for milk and milk products they do not digest quickly in comparison with other proteins as they already have good amount of fats.

 

6. Melons with any other foods

Melons are most quickly digested than any other foods and may cause fermentation, if combined with other foods.

Therefore they are best when eaten alone.

 

 7. Large quantity of liquids with solid foods should be avoided

Large quantity of liquid should be avoided with solid foods the reason is that liquids pass through the intestine very fast. If they are held for a long time due to combination of solid foods they may cause fermentation.

May also wash away the digestive enzymes and hinder digestion.

Therefore any liquids should not be taken immediately before or after a meal. Taken 1 hour post the meal will be beneficial.

 

I know I have put in too many wrong combinations, but I have some good news too.

There are some foods and factors that can lower the effect of such combinations.

So let’s jump into it –

  • A strong digestive fire (if we are blessed) can be the most powerful tool to deal with bad food combinations
  • If our body is accustomed to a certain food combination through many years of use then it is likely that our body has got accustomed to this.

For instance – A  lot of us have daal and curd combinations for eg kadhi , dahiwada , khichdi with curd and it would not cause digestive issues for most this is because the body is accustomed to that combination since years , but we even got to understand that its not the best that your body can digest.

  • Eating a bad combination occasionally will not affect the digestion too much, the only thing that should be kept in mind is that it should not happen too frequently.

Tips to aid digestion

  • Eat little grated ginger along with rock salt (pinch) before each meal to stimulate “AGNI”
  • Alkali foods help in digestion and regulates gastric fire

List of alkali foods –

Alkaline Foods aid digestion

 

  • Pure cow’s Ghee stimulates AGNI and improves digestion.
  • Small sips of water during a meal will aid digestion and absorption of foods. Do not have large amount of water though.
  • Do not drink iced water as it slows AGNI and digestion.
  • Proper chewing is essential to good digestion ensuring food gets thoroughly mixed with saliva. This is will aid digestion process.
  • A cup of buttermilk at the end of a meal also aids the digestive process as it is rich in gut friendly microbes.
  • Ideally one should fill the stomach with 1/3 food, 1/3 liquid, 1/3 should be empty therefore never over eat.

 

At a glance

Proper Food Combinations

 

We even have certain nutrients which when taken in right combination can improve absorption

  1. Vitamin C and Iron

Eating foods rich in vitamin C can improve iron absorption.

So squeezing lemon in your meals or having more foods which are rich in vitamin c will help you absorb more iron

Sources of vitamin C are – citrus fruits / capsicums / cabbage / lemons etc

Suggested Read, 10 Foods so rich in Vitamin C, you’ll never need a supplement again!!

 

  1. Vitamin D for calcium and phosphorous

Calcium absorption can be improved by loading you body with good amount of vitamin D.

Vitamin D will improve the absorption of these minerals from the digestive tract and inhibit calcium excretion from urine.

Sources of vitamin d are exposure to sun , fatty fish , eggs.

 

  1. Vitamin K and Calcium

Vitamin k works with vitamin D to help body absorb and use calcium effectively , this in turn helps to improve bone health

Sources include – broccoli, Brussels sprouts, chick peas, kale, eggs and dairy.

 

  1. Fatty acids and antioxidants

Fats help absorb fat soluble vitamins like vitamin D , vitamin E , Vitamin A and Vitamin K

Some among these are high on antioxidant power.

Medium chain fatty acids are even better as they are smaller than the fatty acids found in most other oils and therefore enter the cell membrane easily.

So have that olive oil dressing, or throw in some nuts over your salad 🙂

 

  1. Probiotics and other nutrients

Probiotics mainly curd which comes naturally helps to improve gut friendly bacteria which in turn help in better nutrient absorption.

Have no qualms about having a cup of curd every day!

So that was my two cents about Viruddha Aahar. Hope you can use this information to better your health.

 

References:
  1. Tumran, A. C. (2014). Review on Therapeutic Significance of Viruddh Aahar. International Journal of Research in Ayurveda and Pharmacy, 5(4), 571-574.
  2. Talekar, M. (2015). Role of Viruddha Aahar in Kushta (Skin Disease): An Epidemiological Study. International Journal of Research in Ayurveda and Pharmacy, 6(3), 335-341.
  3. Viruddhahara(Antagonistic food) | National Health Portal of India [https://www.nhp.gov.in/viruddhahara-antagonistic-food-_mtl]
  4. Kulkarni, M. (2016). A cross-sectional study to assess the incompatible dietary behavior of patients suffering from skin diseases: A pilot study. Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine, 7(2), 113-118. doi:10.1016/j.jaim.2016.06.001
  5. Sabnis, M. (2012). Viruddha Ahara: A critical view. An International Quarterly Journal of Research in Ayurveda, 33(3), 332-336. doi:10.4103/0974-8520.108817

 

Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator

Her fitness mantra is “do not start with a diet that has an expiration date, instead, focus on a healthy lifestyle that will last forever”. Disti has completed post graduation in Clinical Nutrition and Dietetics. She is also a certified Diabetes Educator.
She is keen on bringing together her acquired knowledge on nutrition and other health aspects with people’s goals to achieve a healthy life. For her fitness is not being better than someone else; it’s about being better than who we used to be. “We don’t have to be great to start, but we have to start to be great”. So give your best!

Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator

Disti Vira, Dietitian, Certified Diabetes Educator

Her fitness mantra is “do not start with a diet that has an expiration date, instead, focus on a healthy lifestyle that will last forever”. Disti has completed post graduation in Clinical Nutrition and Dietetics. She is also a certified Diabetes Educator.
She is keen on bringing together her acquired knowledge on nutrition and other health aspects with people’s goals to achieve a healthy life. For her fitness is not being better than someone else; it’s about being better than who we used to be. “We don’t have to be great to start, but we have to start to be great”. So give your best!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *